Join our WikiEducator discussion group or Register now for free skills training.

View source

From WikiEducator

Jump to: navigation, search

Come now JT! Mentioning that Downes' blog post on WikiEd on the front page hardly seems like "milking" it to me. Wikiversity would have done the same; not to mention that i've been looking at the stats today re: both Wikiversity and WikiEd and I'd actually tend to agree with him that Wikied is really more active in a way. Particularly when you look at the edits that actually take place on Wikiversity - the majority of them are done by Custodians and the Colloquium is probably the most active space on the entire site. There's no reason to start Wikied vs Wikiv again -- i based my custodianship on the exact opposite - of trying to bring the OER projects closer together, not make islands of them. Why not do the same?

Fair call, Brent. Numbers don't mean much; attitude does; I agree collective OER efforts are what matters. Interesting point about "non-sysop" edits; I think that's a useful criteria evaluative criteria (say for internal benchmarking). Much WV activity (esp. new account registrations) probably also comes from sisproject editors. Downes' list was long, so perhaps unfair to criticise his lack of citation. Also WE stats are transparently displayed on the Main Page, to its credit. Jtneill 11:14, 19 May 2008 (UTC)

You do not have permission to edit pages, for the following reason:

The action you have requested is limited to users in the group: Users.

You can view and copy the source of this page:

Return to Thread:Downes (2).

Brent, JT

From my perspective WV and WE are "two leaves on the same tree" to cite Country Mike. I also think that there is considerable value in comparing and evaluating our collective experiences. WE has learned a lot from the WMF projects and we try to learn from these experiences. For example -- I was very surprised to see the productivity of the WE community comparing the ratio of pages to registered users.

We've been pretty successful in extending our work in the developing world and as Brent has pointed out, a lot of energy goes into capacity development in using MW technology.

For those interested -- you can view our daily stats here:

http://wikieducator.org/stats/

Ultimately the diversity in our OER projects will contribute to a better world for all involved.